Columbus Crew Overview

Basic Information

Franchise History

The Columbus Crew were one of the ten founding clubs of Major League Soccer, making them one of the most historically significant franchises in American professional soccer. The team was established by Lamar Hunt, the legendary sports entrepreneur who also founded the American Football League and owned the Kansas City Chiefs.

The Crew’s establishment in Columbus represented MLS’s commitment to placing teams in markets with demonstrated soccer interest rather than simply the largest cities. The franchise has rewarded that faith with three MLS Cup championships, making them one of the most successful original MLS clubs.

The Crew’s history includes one of the most dramatic stories in American sports: the “Save the Crew” movement that prevented the team from relocating to Austin, Texas, in 2018. The successful fan-led effort to save the franchise demonstrated the deep connection between the team and the Columbus community.

Team Identity

Name and Logo

The team name “Crew” was chosen to reflect the working-class identity of Columbus and the industrial heritage of the American Midwest. The name also evokes the teamwork and collective effort required in soccer.

The original logo featured three construction workers (hard hats, jackhammer, and saw) in a circle, representing the “crew” concept. The current logo, introduced in 2021, is a modernized circular crest featuring a stylized “C” with the number 96 (representing the inaugural season) integrated into the design.

The black and gold color scheme was inspired by the Columbus city flag and creates a distinctive visual identity in MLS.

Mascot

The Crew’s mascot is Crew Cat, a black cat who entertains fans during home matches. The character has been part of the franchise since its early years and remains popular with younger supporters.

Current Status

As of the 2020s, the Columbus Crew have established themselves as one of MLS’s model franchises. Under head coach Wilfried Nancy (hired 2022), the team won MLS Cup 2023, their third championship. The Crew play an attractive, possession-based style that has earned praise throughout the league.

The team plays in the modern Lower.com Field, which opened in 2021 as part of the Confluence Village development. The stadium represents the culmination of the “Save the Crew” victory and provides the franchise with a state-of-the-art home.

The “Save the Crew” Movement

The Threat (2017)

On October 17, 2017, Anthony Precourt, then-owner of the Crew, announced his intention to move the team to Austin, Texas, unless a downtown stadium deal could be secured in Columbus. The announcement shocked the MLS community and Crew supporters.

The Response

Crew supporters organized the “Save the Crew” movement, launching a grassroots campaign to keep the team in Columbus. The movement included: - Social media campaigns using #SaveTheCrew - Rallies and demonstrations in Columbus - Legal challenges to the relocation - Engagement with local and state politicians - Partnerships with local business leaders

The Victory (2018)

In December 2018, the Haslam family (owners of the Cleveland Browns) and Pete Edwards announced they would purchase the Crew from Precourt, keeping the team in Columbus. The announcement was celebrated as a victory for fan activism in American sports.

The “Save the Crew” movement is now studied as a case study in successful sports fan activism and demonstrated the power of organized supporter groups in American soccer.

Columbus Crew History

Founding and Early Years (1994-1999)

MLS Inaugural Franchise

The Columbus Crew were announced as one of Major League Soccer’s ten inaugural franchises on June 15, 1994. The team was awarded to Lamar Hunt, who paid the $5 million expansion fee to establish the club. Hunt’s vision was to create a soccer-specific culture in a mid-sized American city.

The First Coach and Players

Tom Fitzgerald was hired as the Crew’s first head coach. The team held its inaugural player draft and built a roster mixing American players with international talent. Brian McBride was selected in the 1996 MLS Inaugural Player Draft and would become the face of the franchise.

Inaugural Season (1996)

The Crew played their first MLS match on April 13, 1996, defeating D.C. United 4-0 at Ohio Stadium. Brian Maisonneuve scored the first goal in franchise history. The team finished their first season with a 15-17 record, missing the playoffs.

Ohio Stadium Era (1996-1999)

The Crew played their first four seasons at Ohio Stadium, the home of the Ohio State Buckeyes football team. While the venue was far larger than needed for soccer (capacity over 90,000), it provided the Crew with a prestigious home and demonstrated the team’s ambition.

Average attendance during the Ohio Stadium years was modest but established a foundation of support that would grow in future years.

The Historic Crew Stadium Era (1999-2021)

First Soccer-Specific Stadium (1999)

On May 15, 1999, the Columbus Crew opened Historic Crew Stadium (originally Columbus Crew Stadium), the first soccer-specific stadium built for an MLS team. The stadium’s construction was a landmark moment for American soccer, proving that MLS could support purpose-built venues rather than sharing oversized American football stadiums.

The stadium seated approximately 22,000 fans and featured a natural grass field. Its success inspired other MLS teams to pursue their own soccer-specific stadiums, transforming the league’s infrastructure.

The Brian McBride Era

Brian McBride emerged as the face of the Crew during the late 1990s and early 2000s. The American striker combined technical skill with aerial ability and became one of the best players in MLS history. McBride was a three-time MLS Best XI selection with Columbus and led the team to their first trophies.

McBride’s success with the Crew led to a transfer to Fulham in the English Premier League, where he became a fan favorite and one of the most successful American players in Europe.

U.S. Open Cup Championship (2002)

The 2002 season brought the Crew their first major trophy. On October 24, 2002, Columbus defeated the Los Angeles Galaxy 1-0 at Historic Crew Stadium to win the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup. The victory was particularly meaningful as it came in Lamar Hunt’s stadium, honoring the founder’s commitment to American soccer.

MLS Cup Heartbreak (2002)

The 2002 season also brought heartbreak in the MLS Cup Playoffs. The Crew reached MLS Cup 2002 but were defeated 1-0 by the Los Angeles Galaxy at Gillette Stadium in Foxborough, Massachusetts. Despite the loss, the season established Columbus as a legitimate contender.

The Guillermo Barros Schelotto Era (2007-2010)

Argentine playmaker Guillermo Barros Schelotto joined the Crew in 2007 and transformed the franchise. The former Boca Juniors star brought world-class skill and creativity to Columbus, earning MLS MVP honors in 2008.

Barros Schelotto’s vision, passing, and set-piece ability made him one of the most entertaining players in MLS history. His connection with the Columbus community and passionate style of play endeared him to fans.

First MLS Cup Championship (2008)

The 2008 season culminated in the greatest achievement in Crew history. Under head coach Sigi Schmid, Columbus finished with the best regular season record (57 points) and dominated the playoffs.

In MLS Cup 2008, played at Home Depot Center in Carson, California, the Crew defeated the New York Red Bulls 3-1. Chad Marshall, Guillermo Barros Schelotto, and Alejandro Moreno scored the goals, while Barros Schelotto was named MLS Cup MVP.

The championship was the first for Columbus and validated years of building under Lamar Hunt’s vision. Sadly, Lamar Hunt passed away in 2006 and did not live to see his team lift the trophy, but his legacy was honored throughout the championship run.

Supporters’ Shield Wins

The Crew have won the Supporters’ Shield (awarded to the team with the best regular season record) three times: - 2004 (49 points) - 2008 (57 points) - 2009 (49 points)

These accomplishments established Columbus as one of the most consistent regular season teams in MLS during the 2000s.

The Middle Years (2010-2017)

Post-Championship Transition

Following the 2008 MLS Cup victory, the Crew experienced a period of transition. Sigi Schmid departed for Seattle, and Robert Warzycha took over as head coach. The team remained competitive, winning the Supporters’ Shield in 2009, but struggled to recapture championship form.

The Robert Warzycha Era

Robert Warzycha, a former Crew player, served as head coach from 2009 to 2013. Under Warzycha, the team made the playoffs consistently but failed to advance deep into the postseason. The era was marked by solid regular season play and playoff disappointment.

The Gregg Berhalter Era Begins (2013)

In 2013, Gregg Berhalter was hired as head coach and sporting director, giving him unprecedented control over the franchise’s soccer operations. Berhalter implemented a possession-based style and began rebuilding the roster with an emphasis on technical ability.

Under Berhalter, the Crew reached MLS Cup 2015, losing 2-1 to the Portland Timbers at MAPFRE Stadium. The appearance demonstrated that Columbus was once again a contender.

The Anthony Precourt Era and “Save the Crew” (2013-2018)

In 2013, Anthony Precourt purchased the Crew from the Hunt Sports Group for $68 million. Initially, Precourt’s ownership appeared positive, with continued on-field competitiveness and investment in the team.

However, on October 17, 2017, Precourt announced his intention to relocate the team to Austin, Texas, unless a downtown stadium deal could be secured. The announcement triggered the “Save the Crew” movement, a fan-led effort to keep the team in Columbus.

The movement gained national attention and support from across MLS. Legal challenges were filed, and the Ohio Attorney General investigated potential violations of the Modell Law (named after Art Modell, who moved the Cleveland Browns), which requires advance notice for relocating sports teams using publicly funded facilities.

The Haslam and Edwards Purchase (2018)

On December 28, 2018, the Haslam family (owners of the Cleveland Browns) and Columbus physician Pete Edwards announced they would purchase the Crew from Precourt, keeping the team in Columbus. The announcement was a historic victory for fan activism in American sports.

As part of the deal, Precourt received the rights to establish an expansion team in Austin (Austin FC), while the Crew remained in Columbus with new ownership committed to building a downtown stadium.

Modern Era (2019-Present)

The Caleb Porter Era (2019-2022)

Caleb Porter was hired as head coach in 2019, bringing MLS Cup-winning experience from his time with Portland. In his second season, Porter led the Crew to MLS Cup 2020, played in December 2020 due to COVID-19 pandemic delays.

MLS Cup 2020 Championship

On December 12, 2020, the Columbus Crew defeated Seattle Sounders FC 3-0 at MAPFRE Stadium to win their second MLS Cup championship. Lucas Zelarayan was named MLS Cup MVP after scoring two spectacular goals.

The victory was particularly meaningful as it came during the pandemic, with limited fans in attendance, and demonstrated the resilience of the franchise following the “Save the Crew” battle. The championship was a tribute to the supporters who had fought to keep the team in Columbus.

New Stadium and New Name (2021)

On July 3, 2021, the Crew opened Lower.com Field (then known as New Crew Stadium), their new downtown stadium at Confluence Village. The stadium represents the fulfillment of the promises made during the “Save the Crew” campaign.

The stadium opening coincided with a rebranding that simplified the team name from “Columbus Crew SC” to “Columbus Crew” while maintaining the black and gold colors and core identity.

The Wilfried Nancy Era and Third Championship (2022-Present)

Wilfried Nancy was hired as head coach in 2022, bringing his tactical expertise from CF Montreal. Nancy implemented an attractive, possession-based style that maximized the talents of players like Lucas Zelarayan, Cucho Hernandez, and Darlington Nagbe.

In 2023, Nancy led the Crew to their third MLS Cup championship, defeating Los Angeles FC 2-1 at Lower.com Field on December 9, 2023. Cucho Hernandez was named MLS Cup MVP. The victory cemented the Crew’s status as one of MLS’s most successful franchises.

Historical Significance

The Columbus Crew’s history is intertwined with the development of professional soccer in the United States. From building the first soccer-specific stadium to surviving the “Save the Crew” battle to winning three MLS Cup championships, the Crew have consistently been at the center of American soccer’s evolution.

The franchise’s success on and off the field demonstrates that MLS can thrive in mid-sized American markets when there is strong ownership, community connection, and commitment to the sport.

Columbus Crew Championships

MLS Cup Championships (3)

2008 MLS Cup Champions

Regular Season Record: 17-7-6 (57 points, 1st in MLS - Supporters’ Shield winners)

Head Coach: Sigi Schmid

Captain: Frankie Hejduk

Playoff Run:

Key Players: - Guillermo Barros Schelotto (Forward) - MLS Cup MVP, creative genius - Chad Marshall (Defender) - Anchored the defense, scored in MLS Cup - Alejandro Moreno (Forward) - Work rate and key goal in MLS Cup - Frankie Hejduk (Defender) - Captain and emotional leader - Eddie Gaven (Midfielder) - Consistent two-way play - Robbie Rogers (Midfielder) - Speed and creativity on the wing - Will Hesmer (Goalkeeper) - Reliable presence in goal - Brian Carroll (Midfielder) - Defensive midfield anchor - Gino Padula (Defender) - Veteran leadership on the back line - Chad Marshall (Defender) - MLS Defender of the Year

The Journey: The 2008 Columbus Crew dominated Major League Soccer from start to finish. Under head coach Sigi Schmid, the team combined Guillermo Barros Schelotto’s Argentine creativity with American work rate and athleticism. The Crew won the Supporters’ Shield by a comfortable margin, establishing themselves as the team to beat.

In the playoffs, Columbus dispatched Kansas City and Chicago to reach MLS Cup. The final against the New York Red Bulls was a showcase of the Crew’s superiority. Alejandro Moreno opened the scoring in the 31st minute, followed by Chad Marshall’s header in the 53rd minute. Guillermo Barros Schelotto sealed the victory with a goal in the 82nd minute.

Barros Schelotto was named MLS Cup MVP, capping a remarkable season in which he also won the MLS MVP award. The championship honored the memory of Lamar Hunt, who had passed away in 2006 and whose vision had brought professional soccer to Columbus.

2020 MLS Cup Champions

Regular Season Record: 12-6-5 (41 points, 3rd in Eastern Conference - shortened season)

Head Coach: Caleb Porter

Captain: Jonathan Mensah

Playoff Run:

Key Players: - Lucas Zelarayan (Midfielder) - MLS Cup MVP, two spectacular goals - Artur (Midfielder) - Defensive midfield dominance - Darlington Nagbe (Midfielder) - Experience and composure - Jonathan Mensah (Defender) - Captain and defensive anchor - Gyasi Zardes (Forward) - Goal-scoring threat - Eloy Room (Goalkeeper) - Key saves throughout playoffs - Milton Valenzuela (Defender) - Solid defensive play - Pedro Santos (Midfielder) - Creative spark

The Journey: The 2020 season was unlike any other in MLS history. The COVID-19 pandemic suspended play in March, leading to the creation of the “MLS is Back Tournament” in Orlando. The Crew emerged from the tournament with confidence and carried that momentum through the regular season.

The playoffs were played in December due to pandemic delays, with limited fans in attendance at MAPFRE Stadium. The Crew hosted every playoff game, taking advantage of their home field.

In MLS Cup, the Crew faced the Seattle Sounders, two-time MLS Cup champions and the dominant team of the era. Columbus dominated from the opening whistle, with Lucas Zelarayan scoring two stunning goals and Derrick Etienne Jr. adding a third. The 3-0 victory was the largest margin of victory in MLS Cup history.

The championship was especially meaningful as it came just two years after the “Save the Crew” victory. The trophy represented the fulfillment of the promises made by the new ownership and the resilience of the Columbus community.

2023 MLS Cup Champions

Regular Season Record: 16-9-9 (57 points, 3rd in Eastern Conference)

Head Coach: Wilfried Nancy

Captain: Darlington Nagbe

Playoff Run:

Key Players: - Cucho Hernandez (Forward) - MLS Cup MVP, match-winning goal - Darlington Nagbe (Midfielder) - Captain, midfield general - Lucas Zelarayan (Midfielder) - Playoff heroics, spectacular goals - Patrick Schulte (Goalkeeper) - Rookie who became playoff starter - Malte Amundsen (Defender) - Solid defensive play - Steven Moreira (Defender) - Defensive anchor - Julian Gressel (Midfielder) - Set-piece specialist - Christian Ramirez (Forward) - Clutch goal-scoring - Yaw Yeboah (Midfielder) - Energy and creativity

The Journey: Under first-year head coach Wilfried Nancy, the Crew implemented an attractive, possession-based style that earned praise throughout MLS. The team finished third in the East and entered the playoffs as a dangerous contender.

The playoff run featured dramatic moments, including the “Hell Is Real” derby victory over FC Cincinnati in the Conference Final. The match went to extra time, with Christian Ramirez scoring the winner to send Columbus to MLS Cup.

Hosting MLS Cup at Lower.com Field for the first time, the Crew faced LAFC and their superstar Carlos Vela. Cucho Hernandez scored the winning goal in the 33rd minute, and the Crew held on for a 2-1 victory. The victory made Columbus the first MLS team to win three MLS Cup championships at home (or at their designated home stadium).

Additional Trophy Honors

Supporters’ Shield (3)

The Supporters’ Shield is awarded to the team with the best regular season record in MLS.

Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup (1)

2002 U.S. Open Cup Champions

Final: October 24, 2002 vs. Los Angeles Galaxy at Historic Crew Stadium Result: Columbus Crew 1, Los Angeles Galaxy 0 Goal: Freddy Garcia (20th minute)

The 2002 U.S. Open Cup victory was the first major trophy in franchise history. The match was played at Historic Crew Stadium in front of passionate supporters. Freddy Garcia’s first-half goal stood up as the winner, and the victory was especially meaningful as it came in Lamar Hunt’s stadium, honoring the founder’s legacy.

Campeones Cup (1)

2021 Campeones Cup Champions

The Campeones Cup is an annual competition between the MLS Cup champions and the Liga MX champions.

Match: September 29, 2021 vs. Cruz Azul at Lower.com Field Result: Columbus Crew 2, Cruz Azul 0 (after extra time) Goals: Jonathan Mensah, Miguel Berry

The 2021 Campeones Cup victory was Columbus’s first international trophy. After a scoreless 90 minutes, Jonathan Mensah and Miguel Berry scored in extra time to defeat the Mexican champions in front of the home crowd.

Individual Awards Won by Crew Players

Landon Donovan MVP Award

• 2008: Guillermo Barros Schelotto
• 2023: Luciano Acosta (FC Cincinnati) - Crew players have not won MVP since 2008

MLS Cup MVP

• 2008: Guillermo Barros Schelotto
• 2020: Lucas Zelarayan
• 2023: Cucho Hernandez

MLS Defender of the Year

• 2004: Robin Fraser
• 2008: Chad Marshall
• 2009: Chad Marshall

MLS Goalkeeper of the Year

• 2004: Jon Busch
• 2009: Donovan Ricketts

MLS Newcomer of the Year

• 2008: Guillermo Barros Schelotto
• 2022: Cucho Hernandez

MLS Rookie of the Year

• 2023: not awarded to Crew player

MLS Coach of the Year

• 2004: Greg Andrulis
• 2008: Sigi Schmid
• 2023: Wilfried Nancy

Near Misses

MLS Cup 2002

The Crew reached MLS Cup 2002 but were defeated 1-0 by the Los Angeles Galaxy. The loss was particularly painful as it came during the franchise’s most successful season to that point.

MLS Cup 2015

Under Gregg Berhalter, the Crew reached MLS Cup 2015 but lost 2-1 to the Portland Timbers. The match was competitive, but Portland’s Diego Valeri scored an early goal that set the tone.

2004 MLS Cup Playoffs

The 2004 Supporters’ Shield-winning Crew were upset in the Eastern Conference Final by the Kansas City Wizards, falling one win short of MLS Cup.

2009 MLS Cup Playoffs

The defending champion Crew were upset in the Eastern Conference Semifinals by Real Salt Lake, who went on to win MLS Cup.

The Columbus Crew’s trophy case is among the most impressive in MLS history, with three MLS Cup championships, three Supporters’ Shields, and a U.S. Open Cup title establishing them as one of the league’s most successful franchises.

Columbus Crew Team Records

Single Season Records

Points and Standings

Offensive Records

Defensive Records

Individual Records

Career Records

Scoring

Goalkeeping

Single Season Records

Scoring

Goalkeeping

Playoff Records

Individual Single Playoff Year

Team Playoff Records

Streak Records

Winning Streaks

Head-to-Head Records

All-Time Record vs. Select Opponents (Through 2024)

“Hell Is Real” Derby vs. FC Cincinnati

The “Hell Is Real” derby is named after a billboard on I-71 between Columbus and Cincinnati displaying the message “Hell Is Real.” The rivalry has become one of the most intense in MLS.

Draft Records

Notable Draft Picks

Homegrown Players

• Wil Trapp (2013)
• Zack Steffen (2015)
• Alex Crognale (2016)
• Isaiah Parente (2021)

Notable Achievements

Individual Awards by Crew Players

Firsts

Attendance Records

Single Match Records

Season Attendance Records

Coaching Records

Most Games Coached

Best Winning Percentage (min. 50 games)

Columbus Crew Legendary Players

Franchise Icons

Brian McBride

Position: Forward Years with Crew: 1996-2003 Number: 20

Brian McBride is the original Columbus Crew icon and one of the most important players in American soccer history. Selected in the 1996 MLS Inaugural Player Draft, McBride became the face of the franchise during its formative years.

McBride combined technical skill with incredible aerial ability, making him one of the most dangerous forwards in MLS. He was a three-time MLS Best XI selection (1996, 1997, 1998) and led the Crew to the 2002 U.S. Open Cup championship.

His success with Columbus led to a transfer to Fulham in the English Premier League, where he became a club legend and captain. McBride represented the United States in three World Cups (1998, 2002, 2006) and was known for his toughness, professionalism, and clutch performances.

McBride’s number 20 was retired by the Crew, and he remains involved with the organization as a club ambassador. His statue stands outside Lower.com Field, honoring his contributions to Columbus and American soccer.

Guillermo Barros Schelotto

Position: Forward/Midfielder Years with Crew: 2007-2010 Number: 7

Guillermo Barros Schelotto transformed the Columbus Crew from a solid MLS team into champions. The Argentine maestro joined Columbus in 2007 after a storied career with Boca Juniors in Argentina, where he won numerous titles including the Copa Libertadores.

In 2008, Barros Schelotto had one of the greatest individual seasons in MLS history: 7 goals and 19 assists (then a league record), earning him both the MLS MVP and MLS Cup MVP awards. His vision, passing, and creativity were unmatched in the league, and his partnership with Alejandro Moreno and Eddie Gaven created a dynamic attack.

Barros Schelotto’s influence extended beyond statistics. His professionalism, passion, and connection with fans made him a beloved figure in Columbus. He led the Crew to their first MLS Cup championship in 2008 and also won the Supporters’ Shield in 2008 and 2009.

After retiring, Barros Schelotto became a manager, but his playing legacy in Columbus remains unmatched. He is widely considered the greatest player in Crew history.

Modern Era Stars

Lucas Zelarayan

Position: Midfielder Years with Crew: 2020-2023 Number: 10

Lucas Zelarayan was the catalyst for two MLS Cup championships (2020 and 2023) and established himself as one of the best Designated Players in MLS history. The Argentine midfielder joined Columbus from Tigres UANL in Liga MX in 2020.

Zelarayan’s MLS Cup 2020 performance was legendary: two spectacular goals against Seattle, including a stunning long-range strike, earned him MLS Cup MVP honors. His ability to score from distance, create chances, and control the tempo made him the perfect player for Wilfried Nancy’s system.

In 2023, Zelarayan again delivered in the playoffs, scoring crucial goals to help the Crew win their third MLS Cup. He was named to the MLS Best XI in 2020 and 2023 before departing for Al-Fateh in Saudi Arabia in 2023.

Darlington Nagbe

Position: Midfielder Years with Crew: 2020-Present Number: 6

Darlington Nagbe is the engine of the modern Columbus Crew and one of the most successful American players in MLS history. Acquired from Atlanta United in 2019, Nagbe brought championship experience and elite passing ability to Columbus.

Nagbe has won four MLS Cup championships (Portland 2015, Atlanta 2018, Columbus 2020 and 2023), making him one of the most decorated players in league history. His ability to retain possession under pressure, connect passes, and control the tempo is unmatched in MLS.

Named team captain in 2022, Nagbe represents the leadership and professionalism that defines the Crew culture. His consistent excellence and durability (he rarely misses games) make him invaluable to the team’s success.

Cucho Hernandez

Position: Forward Years with Crew: 2022-2024 Number: 9

Cucho Hernandez arrived from Watford in the English Premier League in 2022 and immediately became one of the most exciting players in MLS. The Colombian forward combined explosive speed, technical ability, and clinical finishing.

In 2023, Hernandez led the Crew to MLS Cup glory, scoring the winning goal in the final against LAFC and earning MLS Cup MVP honors. His 24 goals in 2024 set a new Crew single-season record.

Hernandez was named MLS Newcomer of the Year in 2022 and earned multiple Best XI selections. His departure to Real Betis in Spain in 2024 marked the end of a spectacular two-and-a-half year tenure in Columbus.

Defensive Legends

Chad Marshall

Position: Defender Years with Crew: 2004-2013 Number: 14

Chad Marshall was the defensive anchor for the most successful period in Crew history. Drafted second overall in 2004, Marshall won the MLS Defender of the Year award twice (2008, 2009) and was a key member of the 2008 MLS Cup championship team.

Marshall’s aerial ability, positioning, and leadership made him one of the best center backs in MLS history. He scored the crucial second goal in MLS Cup 2008 and consistently shut down opposing attackers.

Marshall played 253 games for the Crew before finishing his career with Seattle Sounders FC. He remains the standard for defensive excellence in Columbus.

Frankie Hejduk

Position: Defender Years with Crew: 2003-2010 Number: 2

Frankie Hejduk brought infectious energy and American soccer pedigree to the Crew. The former US national team star was known for his tireless running down the right flank, defensive tenacity, and passionate celebrations.

Hejduk served as captain of the 2008 MLS Cup championship team and was a four-time MLS All-Star with Columbus. His connection with fans and community involvement made him a beloved figure in Columbus. Hejduk’s number 2 was retired by the Crew.

Other Notable Players

Jeff Cunningham

Position: Forward Years with Crew: 1998-2003, 2010 Number: 11

Jeff Cunningham is the Crew’s all-time leading scorer with 62 goals. The speedy forward was a consistent goal threat during his first stint with Columbus and returned for a final season in 2010.

Edson Buddle

Position: Forward Years with Crew: 2001-2005

Edson Buddle developed into a dangerous goal scorer with Columbus before moving on to other MLS clubs and the Los Angeles Galaxy. He scored 42 goals in his Crew career.

Eddie Gaven

Position: Midfielder Years with Crew: 2006-2013

Eddie Gaven was a consistent, professional midfielder who contributed to both the 2008 and 2008 Supporters’ Shield teams. His two-way play and durability made him a valuable member of championship teams.

Alejandro Moreno

Position: Forward Years with Crew: 2007-2009

Alejandro Moreno was the perfect complement to Guillermo Barros Schelotto, providing work rate, hold-up play, and key goals. His opening goal in MLS Cup 2008 set the tone for the championship victory.

Wil Trapp

Position: Midfielder Years with Crew: 2013-2019

Wil Trapp was the first homegrown player to make a significant impact with the Crew. The Ohio native became the team’s youngest captain and represented the United States national team. His passing ability and leadership made him a fan favorite before his departure to Inter Miami.

Gyasi Zardes

Position: Forward Years with Crew: 2018-2022

Gyasi Zardes was acquired from the LA Galaxy in 2018 and immediately became a prolific goal scorer for Columbus. He scored 54 goals in five seasons and was instrumental in the 2020 MLS Cup championship. Zardes also became a regular for the US national team during his time in Columbus.

Eloy Room

Position: Goalkeeper Years with Crew: 2019-2023

Eloy Room brought Dutch goalkeeping expertise to Columbus and was the starter for the 2020 MLS Cup championship team. His shot-stopping ability and distribution from the back were key to the team’s success.

Federico Higuain

Position: Forward/Midfielder Years with Crew: 2012-2019 Number: 10

Federico “Pipa” Higuain was a creative force for the Crew during the 2010s. The Argentine playmaker scored 55 goals and added 52 assists in his Crew career. His technical ability and vision made him one of the most entertaining players in team history.

Jonathan Mensah

Position: Defender Years with Crew: 2017-2023 Number: 4

Jonathan Mensah served as team captain and defensive anchor during the 2020 MLS Cup championship run. The Ghanaian international brought leadership and consistency to the back line.

Ring of Honor

The Crew have retired the following numbers: - 2 - Frankie Hejduk - 20 - Brian McBride

These two players represent the standard of excellence for the franchise and are celebrated as the greatest Crew players of all time.

Crew Hall of Fame

The Crew’s organization recognizes legendary players through various honors at Lower.com Field. Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Chad Marshall, and other championship contributors are celebrated throughout the stadium, ensuring their legacies endure for future generations of Crew fans.

Columbus Crew Rivalries

Hell Is Real Derby: FC Cincinnati

Origins

The rivalry between the Columbus Crew and FC Cincinnati is the most significant in Crew history and one of the most intense in Major League Soccer. The rivalry’s name, “Hell Is Real,” comes from a billboard on Interstate 71 between Columbus and Cincinnati displaying the message alongside religious imagery.

The two cities are separated by approximately 110 miles, making it a natural geographic rivalry. The proximity allows for significant away fan presence at matches and creates genuine animosity between the supporter groups.

First Meeting

The teams first met on August 10, 2019, at Nippert Stadium in Cincinnati. FC Cincinnati won the inaugural match 1-0 in front of 30,611 fans. The loss was a bitter pill for Crew supporters, but it set the stage for a competitive rivalry.

2023 MLS Cup Playoffs

The rivalry reached its competitive peak in the 2023 MLS Cup Playoffs. The teams met in the Eastern Conference Final on December 2, 2023, at TQL Stadium in Cincinnati. The match was a thriller, with Columbus defeating Cincinnati 3-2 in extra time.

Christian Ramirez scored the winning goal in extra time, sending Columbus to MLS Cup 2023 and breaking Cincinnati hearts. The victory was particularly sweet for Crew fans given the tensions surrounding the match and Cincinnati’s rise as a competitive force in MLS.

Rivalry Intensity

The Hell Is Real Derby features: - Traveling supporters: Both fanbases travel in large numbers for away matches - Tifo displays: Elaborate pre-game displays from both supporters groups - Social media battles: Intense online engagement between fanbases - Chanting and songs: Specific chants targeting the opposing city and team - Physical play: Matches are often chippy and combative

The rivalry has become must-watch television in MLS and represents the best of what soccer rivalries can be: geographic proximity, competitive balance, and genuine dislike between fanbases.

All-Time Series

The Chicago Fire Rivalry

Historical Significance

The Chicago Fire were the Columbus Crew’s primary rival during MLS’s early years. The Midwest connection and competitive matches between the teams established a rivalry that endured for two decades.

The teams were both founding members of MLS and developed genuine animosity through numerous regular season and playoff battles.

Playoff Meetings

The Crew and Fire met in the MLS Cup Playoffs multiple times: - 1998: Fire defeated Crew in Conference Final - 2002: Fire defeated Crew in Conference Semifinal - 2003: Fire defeated Crew in Conference Semifinal - 2008: Crew defeated Fire in Conference Final (en route to MLS Cup)

The 2008 Conference Final victory was particularly significant as it propelled Columbus to their first MLS Cup championship and exorcised years of playoff demons against Chicago.

Regular Season Battles

The rivalry produced memorable regular season moments, including: - High-scoring matches at both Historic Crew Stadium and Soldier Field - Physical play and numerous red cards - Late goals and dramatic finishes

The rivalry has diminished with Chicago’s struggles in recent years, but the historical significance remains.

The Toronto FC Rivalry

Trillium Cup

The Trillium Cup is the trophy contested between the Columbus Crew and Toronto FC, named after the trillium flower that appears on both Ohio’s and Ontario’s flags.

The rivalry developed during the 2010s as both teams were frequently in competition for playoff positions in the Eastern Conference. The proximity of the cities (approximately 325 miles) allows for traveling fan presence.

Notable Matches

The teams have met in the playoffs and regular season with competitive matches. While not as heated as the FC Cincinnati rivalry, the Trillium Cup represents an important regional competition.

The D.C. United Rivalry

Early MLS Years

D.C. United and the Columbus Crew developed a rivalry during MLS’s early years as two of the original Eastern Conference teams. D.C.’s dominance in the late 1990s created a competitive imbalance, but the Crew’s rise in the 2000s made the matches more competitive.

Lamar Hunt Connection

The rivalry has a special significance due to Lamar Hunt’s ownership of both teams at different times. Hunt founded the Columbus Crew and later acquired D.C. United, creating a unique connection between the franchises.

Recent Meetings

The rivalry has continued with competitive matches in recent years, though it lacks the intensity of the Hell Is Real Derby.

The New England Revolution Rivalry

Playoff Battles

The Crew and New England Revolution have met in the MLS Cup Playoffs multiple times, including: - 2020: Crew defeated Revolution 1-0 in the Eastern Conference Final - 2004: Revolution defeated Crew in the Eastern Conference Final

These playoff meetings have added intensity to the regular season matches between the teams.

Style Contrast

The rivalry is defined by contrasting styles: Columbus’s possession-based approach versus New England’s transition-focused game. The tactical battles between coaches have produced interesting matches.

Emerging Rivalries

Nashville SC

Nashville SC has emerged as a regional rival for the Columbus Crew. The proximity (approximately 380 miles) and similar team profiles have created competitive matches.

The teams met in the 2020 MLS Cup Playoffs, with Columbus defeating Nashville 2-0 in the Conference Semifinals.

Atlanta United FC

Atlanta United FC’s success since entering MLS in 2017 has created a competitive dynamic with the Crew. The teams have met in the playoffs (2023) and feature contrasting styles and markets.

Rivalry Statistics

All-Time Record vs. Major Rivals (Through 2024)

Playoff Record vs. Rivals

Rivalry Culture

Supporters Groups

The Crew’s supporters groups, led by the Nordecke, play an active role in maintaining rivalry intensity: - Tifo displays: Elaborate pre-game displays targeting rivals - Chants and songs: Specific chants for each opponent - Travel coordination: Organized away support for rivalry matches - Community engagement: Rivalry-themed events and fundraisers

The Nordecke

The Nordecke (German for “North Corner”) is the Crew’s primary supporters section, located in the north end of Lower.com Field. The group leads chants, displays tifos, and creates the intimidating atmosphere that defines home matches against rivals.

Media Coverage

Rivalry matches receive heightened media coverage in Columbus and Cincinnati, with local newspapers, radio, and television providing extensive preview and reaction content.

The Future of Crew Rivalries

The Hell Is Real Derby with FC Cincinnati has established itself as one of MLS’s premier rivalries and will continue to define the Crew’s competitive calendar. The geographic proximity and genuine animosity between the fanbases ensure that this rivalry will remain intense for years to come.

As MLS continues to expand, new rivalries may emerge with teams like St. Louis City SC (Midwest proximity) or Charlotte FC (regional competition).

The Crew’s success in the 2020s has elevated their profile, potentially creating new rivalries with other successful MLS franchises.

Columbus Crew Stadium

Lower.com Field

Basic Information

History and Construction

Lower.com Field was built as part of the agreement that saved the Columbus Crew from relocation to Austin, Texas. The stadium represents the fulfillment of promises made by new owners Dee and Jimmy Haslam and Pete Edwards during the “Save the Crew” campaign.

Groundbreaking occurred in 2019, with the stadium opening in July 2021. The naming rights were acquired by Lower.com, an online mortgage lender based in Columbus. The stadium is located at Confluence Village, a mixed-use development at the confluence of the Scioto and Olentangy Rivers.

The stadium opening coincided with a rebranding of the team, simplifying the name from “Columbus Crew SC” to “Columbus Crew” while maintaining the black and gold colors.

Inaugural Match

The Crew played their first match at Lower.com Field on July 3, 2021, defeating the New England Revolution 2-1 in front of a capacity crowd. Lucas Zelarayan scored the first goal in the new stadium, which was particularly fitting given his status as the team’s star player.

Design and Features

Stadium Bowl

Lower.com Field features a steep, intimate bowl design that brings fans close to the action. The single-tier design ensures excellent sightlines from all seats, with the closest seats just yards from the touchline.

The stadium’s capacity of 20,371 was intentionally set to create demand and an intimate atmosphere. The design allows for future expansion if demand warrants.

The Nordecke

The Nordecke, the Crew’s primary supporters section, is located in the north end of the stadium. The section features: - Safe standing (rail seating) for enhanced supporter experience - A dedicated tifo deployment system - Proximity to the field for maximum impact - A canopy to amplify supporter noise

Premium Seating

The stadium includes various premium options: - Loge Boxes: Semi-private seating areas - Field Club: Premium club with field-level views - Suites: Private suites for corporate partners - Upper 96 Club: Premium club in the upper deck

The Confluence Village Development

Mixed-Use Development

The stadium is the anchor of Confluence Village, a broader development that includes: - Office space: Corporate offices and coworking spaces - Residential: Apartments and condominiums - Retail: Restaurants, bars, and shops - Hotel: Planned hotel development - Park space: Public parks and riverfront access

The development transforms a previously underutilized area of Columbus into a vibrant mixed-use neighborhood.

Olentangy Riverfront

The stadium’s location at the confluence of the Scioto and Olentangy Rivers provides: - Scenic views from premium areas - Walking and biking trails - Connection to Columbus’s riverfront development

Notable Events

Crew Matches

• First MLS Match: July 3, 2021 vs. New England Revolution (2-1 win)
• First Playoff Match: November 7, 2021 vs. Nashville SC (3-0 loss)
• MLS Cup 2023: December 9, 2023 vs. Los Angeles FC (2-1 win)
• Hell Is Real Derby matches vs. FC Cincinnati

Other Events

Lower.com Field hosts various non-soccer events: - Concerts (limited capacity) - Community events - High school soccer championships - Corporate events

The stadium’s downtown location and modern amenities make it a desirable venue for various events.

Facilities

Locker Rooms

The Crew locker room features modern amenities including: - Individual player lockers - Hydrotherapy pools - Video analysis room - Player lounge and nutrition station - Direct field access

The visiting locker room is well-appointed, reflecting MLS standards for player accommodations.

Training Facility

The Crew’s training facility is located adjacent to the stadium, allowing for efficient practice operations. The facility includes: - Multiple grass training fields - Indoor training space - Sports performance center - Medical and rehabilitation facilities

Location and Accessibility

Downtown Columbus

Lower.com Field is located in downtown Columbus, within walking distance of: - Ohio Statehouse - Short North Arts District - Arena District - Downtown hotels and restaurants

Transportation

• Driving: Accessible via I-70, I-71, and I-670
• Parking: Multiple parking garages and surface lots in the area
• Bus: COTA (Central Ohio Transit Authority) bus service
• Walking: Accessible from downtown hotels and residences
• Biking: Bike racks and bike share stations nearby

Attendance Records

Crew Records at Lower.com Field

The stadium has consistently sold out or approached capacity for significant matches, demonstrating strong demand for Crew soccer in Columbus.

Environmental Sustainability

Lower.com Field was designed with environmental sustainability in mind: - LEED certification pursued - Stormwater management systems - Energy-efficient lighting and HVAC - Sustainable materials and construction practices

Comparison to Historic Crew Stadium

Lower.com Field represents the evolution of the Crew from a pioneering MLS franchise to a modern, professionally operated club with world-class facilities.

Previous Stadiums

Historic Crew Stadium (1999-2021)

• Capacity: 19,968 (originally 22,500 before renovations)
• Opened: May 15, 1999
• Significance: First soccer-specific stadium in MLS history
• Final Match: June 19, 2021 vs. Chicago Fire

Historic Crew Stadium was a landmark facility that proved MLS could support soccer-specific venues. The stadium hosted: - 2001 MLS All-Star Game - 2002 MLS Cup - 2003 Women’s World Cup matches - 2015 MLS Cup - Multiple U.S. Men’s and Women’s National Team matches

The stadium was renamed Historic Crew Stadium following the move to Lower.com Field and is now used for training and academy matches.

Ohio Stadium (1996-1999)

• Capacity: 90,000+
• Years: 1996-1999
• Notes: Shared with Ohio State football; challenging atmosphere for soccer

The Crew played their first four seasons at Ohio Stadium, the home of Ohio State football. While the venue was far too large for soccer, it established the team in Columbus and demonstrated the potential for professional soccer in the city.

The move to Historic Crew Stadium in 1999 marked the beginning of the modern era for the franchise and American soccer stadium development.

Columbus Crew Fanbase and Culture

Fanbase Overview

Demographics

The Columbus Crew fanbase is concentrated in Central Ohio, with supporters extending throughout the state. As the first MLS team in the Midwest, the Crew have developed a loyal following that spans multiple generations of soccer fans.

The fanbase includes: - Original supporters: Fans who have supported the team since 1996 - Youth soccer families: Parents and children involved in Ohio’s extensive youth soccer programs - Ohio State connections: Fans who support both the Crew and Ohio State athletics - Soccer enthusiasts: Fans who appreciate the Crew’s historical significance in American soccer - “Save the Crew” activists: Supporters who became involved during the 2017-2018 relocation battle

Fan Engagement Metrics

• Season Ticket Members: 12,000-14,000
• Average Attendance: 19,000-20,000 (consistently near capacity at Lower.com Field)
• Waitlist: Several thousand for season tickets
• Nordecke Membership: 2,000+ active supporters
• Social Media Following: 500,000+ combined across platforms

The “Save the Crew” Legacy

Fan Activism as Identity

The “Save the Crew” movement fundamentally shaped modern Crew fan culture. The successful effort to prevent relocation to Austin created: - A sense of ownership and investment in the franchise - Distrust of absentee ownership - Appreciation for local ownership (Haslam/Edwards) - A model for fan activism across American sports

Post-“Save the Crew” Culture

Since the victory, Crew fans have maintained an activist mindset: - Engagement with front office decisions - Community involvement and charitable work - Protective attitude toward the franchise - Celebration of the team’s Columbus identity

The 2020 and 2023 MLS Cup championships were viewed as validation for the fans who fought to keep the team in Columbus.

Supporters Groups

The Nordecke

The Nordecke (German for “North Corner”) is the Crew’s primary supporters group and one of the most influential in MLS. Founded in 2007, the group is named after the German term for the north corner of a stadium, reflecting soccer traditions.

Activities: - Tifo displays before matches - Continuous chanting and singing during games - Organized travel to away matches - Community service and charitable work - Operating the Nordecke tailgate before home matches

Traditions: - The “Wise Men” tifo display honoring Crew legends - “Yellow Card” song and dance - Chants specific to each opponent - Post-match gatherings at local establishments

Other Supporters Groups

• Hudson Street Hooligans: Original supporters group, now part of the Nordecke umbrella
• Crew Union: Organization focused on fan advocacy
• La Turbina Amarilla: Spanish-language supporters group

Fan Culture and Traditions

Game Day Traditions

Tailgating

The Nordecke tailgate is a pre-game tradition where supporters gather for food, drinks, and socializing before matches. The tailgate culture is an essential part of the Crew experience.

March to the Match

Supporters organize a march from the tailgate area to the stadium gates, featuring chanting, drumming, and flag-waving.

The Nordecke Experience

Inside the stadium, the Nordecke section operates continuously throughout matches: - Capo Stands: Designated leaders who coordinate chants - Drums: Constant percussion providing rhythm - Flags and Banners: Large displays creating visual atmosphere - Smoke: Colored smoke celebrations after Crew goals

Chants and Songs

The Crew supporters have developed a repertoire of chants, including: - “Glory Glory Columbus” (to “Glory Glory Man United”) - “Columbus Till I Die” - “We Love Ya” - Player-specific chants - Spontaneous reactions to match events

Jersey Traditions

Crew fans proudly wear black and gold. The supporters’ section is particularly notable for creating a unified visual display through coordinated jersey wearing and flag-waving.

Community Involvement

Crew Foundation

The Columbus Crew Foundation supports various community initiatives: - Youth soccer programs throughout Ohio - Educational initiatives - Health and wellness programs - Military and first responder appreciation

Nordecke Community Work

The supporters group is actively involved in: - Food drives and charitable donations - Youth soccer equipment donations - Volunteer work in Columbus communities - Partnerships with local non-profits

Youth Soccer Development

The Crew have invested significantly in Ohio youth soccer: - Crew Soccer Academy (youth academy) - Camps and clinics throughout the state - High school coaching education - Field refurbishment projects

Media Coverage

Broadcast Partners

• Apple TV (MLS Season Pass): All matches streaming (2023-present)
• Bally Sports Ohio: Select regional broadcasts
• Crew.com: Official team website with exclusive content
• 97.1 The Fan: Radio broadcasts

Broadcast Personalities

• Play-by-Play: Neil Sika
• Color Commentator: Jordan Angeli
• Radio: Chris Doran

Regional and National Perception

MLS Standing

The Columbus Crew are widely respected in MLS for: - Historical significance as an original franchise - Three MLS Cup championships - The “Save the Crew” victory - Development of soccer-specific stadiums - Youth development and academy production

Media Narrative

National coverage of the Crew focuses on: - The “Save the Crew” story as a model for fan activism - The team’s success since the ownership change - Wilfried Nancy’s attractive playing style - The black and gold brand identity

Underdog Status

Despite their success, the Crew are often portrayed as a small-market team that competes through smart management rather than big spending. This narrative resonates with fans who appreciate the team’s approach.

Economic Impact

Local Economy

The Crew contribute to the Columbus economy through: - Game day spending at Lower.com Field and the Arena District - Confluence Village development - Employment opportunities - Tourism from visiting team fans - Youth soccer program participation

Neighborhood Transformation

The construction of Lower.com Field at Confluence Village continues the transformation of Columbus’s riverfront. The development has spurred residential, commercial, and recreational investment in the area.

Fan Challenges

Ohio State Competition

The Ohio State Buckeyes football program dominates the Columbus sports landscape. The Crew compete for attention and media coverage with one of college football’s premier programs.

Market Size

Columbus is a mid-sized market compared to coastal MLS cities. The Crew must maximize their resources and develop homegrown talent to compete with teams in larger markets.

Retaining Star Players

The Crew have lost star players to bigger markets (Lucas Zelarayan, Cucho Hernandez), creating frustration among fans who want to see their best players remain in Columbus.

The Future of the Fanbase

The Columbus Crew fanbase appears stronger than ever following the “Save the Crew” victory and recent championships. Key factors for future growth:

Sustained Success

The 2023 MLS Cup championship demonstrated that Columbus can compete for titles. Continued success will maintain and grow the fanbase.

Youth Development

The Crew’s investment in youth soccer creates lifelong fans. Children who participate in Crew programs become future season ticket holders.

Stadium Experience

Lower.com Field provides a world-class match day experience that attracts casual fans and converts them into die-hard supporters.

Community Connection

The Crew’s deep roots in Columbus, cemented by the “Save the Crew” movement, create a bond between team and community that transcends on-field results.

The Columbus Crew fanbase represents the best of American soccer culture: passionate, community-oriented, and committed to the sport’s growth in the United States. The “Save the Crew” victory proved that fans can make a difference, and that legacy continues to define the franchise.